Turning the wheel
Spoked Wheels
We rush across the country on our motorcycles, over highways, crossing mountains and deserts. All on two wheels. The likelihood that these two wheels are spoked is particularly high if you're riding an enduro or a cruiser. However, the wheels are often out of sight and, therefore, out of mind. Even when checking the air pressure, we're more focused on the pressure gauge than on the wheel itself. It’s time for INSIDE Wunderlich to crouch down and take a closer look at the wheels that represent our freedom.
The story begins 4,000 years ago. The spoked wheel was invented then, replacing the heavy, wooden disc wheel. After that, not much happened for a long time. Much later, with the advent of pneumatic tires (Thomson in 1845 / Dunlop in 1888) – initially for bicycles – the so-called artillery wheels appeared. These allowed for the first time to change only the tire-mounted rim instead of the entire wheel. The benefits of fast tire changes were first used by participants in the legendary Gordon Bennett Cup, the precursor of Grand Prix racing.
While Daimler's "riding car" in 1885 still had uncomfortable wooden spoked wheels, the first mass-produced and officially called motorcycle, the Hildebrand & Wolfmüller in 1894, already had (just one!) spoked wheel, the front one. The stress from the connecting rod drive – the engine was a two-cylinder engine with two connecting rods, one on the right and one on the left – directly onto the rear wheel would likely have been too much for a spoked wheel to handle.
Wire-spoked wheels had already existed for a long time, even as large as mill wheels. They proved themselves, and much smaller versions were then used for motorcycles, allowing for the production of light and stable rims.
The spoked wheel endured for a long time but was constantly improved in detail, especially in terms of the materials used for the three main elements: the hub, the spokes, and the rim. In the 1980s, cast wheels appeared, which Bugatti had already used in automobile racing in the 1920s. Cast wheels looked modern and gave designers significantly more creative freedom than spoked wheels did. For a while, Honda used riveted rims called Comstar, which you either loved or didn’t. Yet, the spoked wheel never went out of style. With the simultaneous rise of enduro and chopper bikes, spoked wheels returned for good reasons and still grace these two genres today, as well as some retro bikes. Their advantages are simply too compelling. One sign of this: BMW developed the cross-spoked wheel to use tubeless tires on a spoked rim for the first time. And today? Many bikes still roll on classic spoked wheels alongside ultramodern, ultra-light carbon wheels, just like the Hildebrand & Wolfmüller did 128 years ago.
The renaissance of spoked wheels was no coincidence. In the case of the emerging choppers of the 1980s and today's cruisers, it was certainly for stylistic reasons. For the enduros that appeared almost simultaneously, there were practical technical reasons that still apply today. This is why no serious adventure bike that regularly goes off-road uses cast wheels. The advantage of the spoked wheel is its elasticity and flexibility, which are particularly useful off-road.
The Specialist
The profession of those who build, maintain, and repair spoked wheels is called a wheel builder. We spoke to one of them who still understands, lives, and masters this craft that is almost 150 years old. His name is Stefan Oster, and he runs his wheel workshop on the idyllic island of Oberau in Fachbach, about five kilometres downstream from Bad Ems, not far from Koblenz, located in the middle of the Lahn.
When you enter the charming brick building, whose door is usually open, you suddenly find yourself in another world. Although the machine park includes a lathe, a milling machine, and a drill press, Stefan Oster's work is quite quiet: with a lot of feeling, which has grown from years of experience. He stands at the workbench to measure a wheel that is undoubtedly too small in diameter and too wide for a motorcycle using the dial gauge. The delicate wheel lies almost friction-free on a balancing device, also called a truing stand, with an axle. Without a torque wrench, but with sensitive, concentrated intuition, he eliminates the lateral and radial runout of the wheel – the goal is to set the readings of the dial gauge as small as possible by pre-tensioning the spokes. You are almost reminded of tuning the strings of a freshly completed guitar. "This is one of four wheels of a 1954 Maserati A6CGS. The customer is from northern Germany, has driven two races with the powerful Italian sports car, and brings me the wheels regularly for maintenance." "From northern Germany? Are there no wheel builders there?" "The craft profession of the wheel builder is a dying one. In Germany, there may still be half a dozen such specialists." After Stefan Oster has finished his work, we sit on the bench in front of the wheel workshop and talk about those who are never talked about – the spoked wheels.
IW
Mr. Oster, you have just carefully worked on the wheels of an expensive Italian sports car that is used in racing. Do spoked rims need maintenance? If so, how often and what exactly needs to be done?
Stefan Oster
The same applies to motorcycle spoked wheels as to the Maserati's wheels. There are a few important points to consider. A spoked wheel "works" in operation. The more it has to work, the more demanding the conditions of use are, the more attention should be paid to the spoked wheel. So there is a difference whether I regularly jump, drift, accelerate, and brake in a sandpit with the bike, or if I occasionally roll to the ice cream parlour on Sundays. When inspecting spoked wheels, we first check the wheel's true running and stability. The true running results from the maximum possible reduction of lateral and radial runout. The stability of the wheel is determined by the degree of pre-tensioning of the spokes. For safety reasons, the rule is always: stability comes before true running! This has always been the philosophy of moto crossers, who pre-tension their spokes to the maximum to get stability into the wheel. In case of doubt, poor true running is tolerated, which you wouldn't feel in the field anyway. Incidentally, adjustment and maintenance work are carried out exclusively on the removed bare rim, i.e., without tyres. Only in this way can the true running be adjusted cleanly. This is especially true for radial runout.
IW
So, our next question is almost answered, which was: Can a wobble develop slowly, or is it always caused by an event?
Stefan Oster
Both are possible. Because the wheel works, the spokes lengthen, and the tension goes out of the wheel, poor true running occurs, which can develop into a wobble. Anyone who knows their motorcycle will feel this in the mushy handling of the unstable rim, it is comparable to driving with too little air. This state must be taken seriously. If one spoke becomes loose, others will follow, and in the worst case, the wheel can collapse. If the air pressure is correct, the wheel should definitely be inspected!
In the case of a wobble caused by a sudden overstrain of the wheel, for example, caused by a pothole or a kerb, the rim must necessarily be replaced. As mentioned at the beginning, the spokes connect the hub in the centre with the rim, the true running is set by centring. A rim is made of a profile that is bent into a circle and welded at the joint. Such a rim is always somewhat unstable. It gains its stability in combination with the hub and spokes by centring and pre-tensioning the rim with the hub. If the rim has taken a deforming blow, it can no longer be centred and must necessarily be replaced. The good thing is that you can repair a spoked wheel, while a cast or forged wheel is completely unusable after such a damage event.
Experience also shows that the chassis geometry has an influence on poor true running. This means that a stiff fork with a large stanchion and immersion tube diameter and strong fork bridges or even the Telelever of many BMW motorcycles react more tolerantly to deviating true running than more sensitive chassis.
IW
So, if I feel the described mushiness when riding, there is basically already a need for action. Can I prevent this, is there a way to detect creeping problems early?
Stefan Oster
Yes, there is. It is called the sound test. With the motorcycle on a stand, you first set one wheel, then the other in rotation with your hand. Then you take a medium screwdriver between two fingers in the other hand and lightly tap each spoke on the rotating wheel. All the spokes must ring. But they do not have to sound the same. However, they should never sound dull because then they are without tension, and you should take care of it.
IW
Why do the spokes not have to sound the same?
Stefan Oster
As described above, the spokes connect the hub with the rim. To centre the wheel, all spokes need a basic tension. If the basic tension is present, lateral and radial runout are balanced by tightening one or more spokes. This means that although all spokes have the basic tension, individual spokes may have a higher tension and therefore sound higher than the others. This is not a mistake, but technically necessary. The opinion that all spokes must sound the same persists to this day. If I were to focus only on the sound of the spokes when tensioning, I would not achieve a clean centring, except with ideal components, but they do not exist because they all have tolerances. So, the conclusion is: they can all sound the same, they definitely all must sound, but never dull! This knowledge may also be helpful at the next TÜV visit when it is again said: The spokes do not sound the same.
IW
OK, I am on my adventure bike in the high Atlas and notice I have a wobble. What advice would you give if presumably there is no specialist workshop or wheel builder nearby? Can I help myself?
Stefan Oster
I would like to preface this with the following: In principle, I advise against repair attempts! Every situation must be assessed differently, it can only be assessed seriously on-site anyway. Every rider must decide for themselves and on their own responsibility whether the direct journey to a specialist workshop at low speed represents too high a risk for a possible failure of the wheel.
In such a situation, beyond civilization and with no prospect of professional help, I would do as described above with the moto crossers. The true running is initially secondary, but I need stability in the wheel, so the aim is to bring all the spokes into tension. However, the direct journey to the nearest specialist should, under all circumstances, be carried out with the necessary caution and full awareness of the defective condition of the wheel.
It is important to know in this context that, for example, the screw heads of the cross spokes of the BMW rims have a set screw on the hub side to secure the screw head. So before tightening the spokes in an emergency, these set screws must be loosened and removed. This is not a big deal, but you should know it. This must also be considered if you have to replace a broken spoke under these conditions, beyond civilization.
IW
Which is better, rubber or metal valves?
Stefan Oster
That is a matter of taste.
IW
There are various balancing weights. Is there a recommendation?
Stefan Oster
After centring a spoked wheel is completed, the tyre is mounted. The balancing is always done on the entire system, i.e., on the wheel, consisting of a spoked rim and mounted tyre. This is usually done on the proven balancing stand. Physically, the heaviest part of the wheel moves downwards, and we have to attach an equally heavy weight on the opposite side to eliminate the imbalance. With modern rims, you can assume that the imbalance is primarily caused by the tyre pressure sensor. The type of weight used depends on various influencing factors: With a typical cross-spoke arrangement, I can work with flat adhesive weights, which are now available in different colours and do not disturb the aesthetics. For post-war motorcycles, my customers often prefer the flat to conical weights typical of that time, which are attached to the spoke. There are special ones, for example, for the two-valve BMWs, which can be securely fixed on the spoke. When we talk about pre-war motorcycles, we also use bendable wire, which is neatly wrapped spirally around the spoke. Today's weights are made of zinc alloys, as the use of lead is prohibited. This has a significant disadvantage. Due to the lower specific weight of zinc alloys, the volume increases, and thus the visual prominence of the weights.
IW
Thank you very much, Mr. Oster, for the interesting conversation and the very insightful look into your craft!
Contact
Radspannerei Köhler e. K.
Owner: Stefan Oster
Insel Oberau 1
56133 Fachbach
Tel.: 02603-933 460
Email: [email protected]
Technical questions for the tyre manufacturer Continental
IW
When it comes to spoked wheels, the question always arises as to whether it is permissible to insert an inner tube into a tubeless tyre.
Conti
It's not just the tyre that plays a crucial role here, but also the type of rim!
An inner tube can be inserted into our tubeless tyres without any issues (up to a maximum speed of 210 km/h), BUT only when mounted on tube-type rims (generally spoked rims, without a safety hump).
On tubeless rims (MT-H2 type, typically cast rims with a safety hump, and also on many BMW spoked rims with external spoke nipples), we strongly advise against it! The construction and surface of the tubeless rim can damage the tube or limit its function, which could lead to a sudden loss of air and, potentially, loss of control of the vehicle.
There are special types of rims that can be used both with and without tubes, but these are specifically marked (“Tube-Ready”, “Tube/Tubeless” or similar).
IW
In this context, it is certainly important to clarify whether there are any legal regulations prohibiting this.
Conti
We are not aware of any regulations that explicitly prohibit the use of inner tubes in tubeless RIMS.
However, since tubeless rims are not designed or manufactured according to standards to protect the tube from damage or ensure its proper function, we automatically rule out this application.
Furthermore, our inner tubes are only approved for a maximum speed of 210 km/h (due to the risk of overheating), which would not be allowed on many bikes, as they are often capable of higher speeds.
Regarding the use of inner tubes in tubeless TYRES, the ETRTO (the European Tyre and Rim Technical Organisation) only mentions that the tyre manufacturer must be consulted beforehand. For our tyres, we generally allow this as they are developed and produced accordingly.
We would like to thank Continental Deutschland Reifen GmbH, especially Volker Plett (Application Technology) and Frank Rudolph, for their support.
Good to know
- Spoked wheels consist of a hub, the necessary number of spokes depending on the application, and a rim. The spokes connect the hub to the rim and provide stability to the wheel.
- One advantage of spoked wheels is their flexibility. In the event of bumps or impacts, they can flex – unlike cast wheels – and thus contribute to shock absorption, a valued advantage in off-road conditions.
- Spoked wheels are generally lighter than cast or forged wheels, which can lead to improved acceleration and agility of the motorcycle, as inertia, gyroscopic forces, and unsprung weight are reduced.
- A disadvantage of spoked wheels is their more demanding maintenance. The spokes must be regularly checked and, if necessary, tightened to ensure the correct tension.
- Spokes should only be subjected to tensile stresses; therefore, they are pre-tensioned in such a way that they never encounter compressive stresses under operating conditions, as a compressive load would cause the spoke to buckle.
Typology: With or without tubes
- Spoked wheels can be used both with tubes and tubeless (e.g., BMW cross-spoked wheels). Tubeless wheels have the advantage of being less prone to punctures due to tube ruptures or valve damage (they are lighter – offering more agility). However, they require special tubeless tyres and an airtight seal on the rim.
Advantages and Disadvantages Compared to Cast or Forged Wheels
- Spoked wheels offer better shock absorption and flexibility, which is particularly advantageous for off-road motorcycles and enduros.
- Cast or forged wheels are generally stiffer, providing more precise steering and stability on the road. However, they often require more complex manufacturing and are heavier than spoked wheels.
Cleaning, Care, Maintenance, Spoke Inspection, Preservation
- When cleaning spoked wheels, it is important to thoroughly remove dirt and debris, as these can cause the spokes to corrode.
- Regularly checking the spoke tension is crucial to detect any loosening or over-stretching. Special spoke wrenches are used to tighten the spokes.
- To prevent corrosion, the spokes can be treated with protective agents.
- It is important to identify any damage to the spokes or the rim early on and, if necessary, make adjustments or repairs.
What Not to Do When Handling Spoked Wheels
- When fitting tyres, make sure that no tools or levers rest against the spokes, as this could damage them.
- Avoid using aggressive chemicals when cleaning the spokes, as these can damage the surface of the spokes.
What to Do If There Is a "Wobble" in the Wheel
- If a "wobble" develops in the wheel, meaning the rim is no longer running true, the cause should be identified. This could be due to a loose or overstretched spoke.
- It is advisable to take the motorcycle to a workshop to have the wheel professionally straightened, and the spokes checked and tightened as necessary.
Self-Help on the Road
- While on the road, you can attempt a rough alignment of the wheel using a spoke wrench, at least to ensure a safe continuation of your journey. However, a precise correction should be made at the nearest workshop.
In Case of a Flat: Better to Use Tyre Sealant or a Repair Kit?
- In the event of a flat tyre, it is advisable to use a repair kit to temporarily patch the tyre and allow for continued travel to the nearest workshop. Tyre sealant can also provide a temporary solution in some cases, but it should not be considered a permanent repair method.
Why Spoked Wheels Are Particularly Suitable for Enduro and Off-Road Motorcycles
- Spoked wheels are especially well-suited for off-road use due to their flexibility and shock absorption. They can absorb impacts and vibrations better, making them less prone to damage from bumps on uneven terrain.
- The ability to replace individual spokes makes repairs in the field easier and faster compared to cast or forged wheels, where often the entire rim needs to be replaced.
Disclaimer/Liability Exclusion
All information and notes in INSIDE Wunderlich | in this report | in Wunderlich communication are provided solely for general informational purposes. They do not constitute advice. In particular, they cannot replace individual technical assessments or risk evaluations that take into account the specific circumstances of each case. Where we report on situations, these are always non-binding examples, from which similar circumstances in other cases cannot necessarily be inferred. Every rider is responsible for their own motorcycle. Please take this into consideration.